ARNIANO

Insights · Andrew Clayton

When Sport Tries to Manufacture Excitement

A question about the communications device worn by Major League Baseball pitchers led me to consider something much broader than the rules of the game. PitchCom, introduced in 2022, allows the pitcher and catcher to exchange pitch selections electronically rather than relying on increasingly elaborate signals. It reduces interruptions and the opportunity for signs to be intercepted, while leaving the essential tactical decision — which pitch to throw, and where — largely intact.

The arrival of the universal designated hitter1 in the National League that same year struck me differently. I always enjoyed watching pitchers bat. There was something satisfying about two starting pitchers having to face each other's deliveries, and occasionally one would produce an unexpected hit. A manager might have to decide whether to remove a pitcher who was performing well because his turn came up with runners in scoring position. The introduction of a specialist batter improved the expected offence, but removed a source of what I would call organic variability: unexpected consequences arising from the original structure of the contest.

These changes raise a wider question. How far should the owners and organisers of sport intervene to improve the entertainment product before they begin diminishing the qualities that make it compelling?

Formula One illustrates one aspect of the problem. In earlier decades, mechanical reliability was a major source of uncertainty. A driver with a substantial lead might retire through engine or gearbox failure. Engineering progress has made such outcomes much less frequent. This is an achievement, not a deficiency to be reversed, but it also means that superior car performance is more likely to be reflected in the result.

At the same time, modern circuit design has often reduced the consequences of some driving errors through larger run-off areas, although the safety gains are substantial. Safety Cars, introduced to manage genuine danger, can eliminate gaps accumulated through pace or strategy. Their deployment is not an arbitrary entertainment device, but its competitive effect is nonetheless different from an advantage being won or lost through racing. The Virtual Safety Car2 is one attempt to manage hazards while preserving more of the intervals already established.

A distinction is emerging between unpredictability that follows from the capabilities, decisions and limitations of competitors, and variability introduced by the structure or administration of the event. The first has a causal history the spectator can follow. The second may produce spectacular results, but can loosen the connection between achievement and reward. Formula One's experiment with double points at the final race of 2014 was an unusually explicit attempt to preserve championship uncertainty; it lasted just one season.

NASCAR3 raises a related, but different, problem. Its origins were rooted in competition between cars recognisably associated with those offered by manufacturers. Within the rules, manufacturers and teams could seek advantages through engineering, design and preparation. Some developed better solutions than others, and the resulting differences could stretch the field. Sporting success provided a claim to technical superiority, even if the familiar relationship between winning on Sunday and selling on Monday was always more complicated than the slogan suggested.

For the organiser, however, technical superiority has a cost. Sustained advantages can make an event less closely contested and discourage those who cannot afford to close the gap. Regulation has therefore progressively narrowed the scope for differentiation, motivated by safety, affordability and competitive parity as well as entertainment.

The Next Gen car4 introduced in 2022 represents a substantial step in this direction, with common chassis architecture and numerous components from approved suppliers. Chevrolet, Ford and Toyota still develop distinctive body designs and engines within the rules, while teams compete through setup, simulation, strategy and execution. It would be inaccurate to say that all the cars are identical or that results have become a lottery; the better-funded and more capable teams continue to find advantages. Nevertheless, the space in which a manufacturer can demonstrate distinctive engineering has narrowed considerably.

There is an additional commercial dimension. The organiser not only specifies components but can establish relationships with the companies supplying them. NASCAR's Competition Partner programme, launched in 2021, associated approved technical suppliers with promotional rights. BBS, Goodyear and other component producers were involved, with the programme subsequently expanding. Goodyear's exclusive tyre supply for NASCAR's leading national series dates back to 1997 and has long been accompanied by a wider sponsorship relationship.

Standardisation therefore performs several functions at once. It controls cost and constrains technical advantage, but it can also establish a commercially valuable network of official suppliers. This does not demonstrate that supplier income determines technical regulations. It does mean that the organiser increasingly controls both the engineering framework of the competition and some of the commercial value associated with that framework.

For manufacturers, participation consequently becomes a different proposition. Success is still desirable, but it is a less direct demonstration of an entire vehicle's superiority. The return may lie increasingly in brand exposure, association with successful teams and continued relevance to an established audience. Being present, with an opportunity to win occasionally, may be commercially preferable to leaving that audience entirely to competitors. That is rational marketing, although it changes what the racing is understood to prove.

Meanwhile, NASCAR has experimented with ways of sustaining uncertainty during races and across the championship. Stage points5 offer intermediate objectives, while caution periods and restarts can bunch cars whose gaps had been built over many laps. Not every caution is discretionary, and close racing at Daytona also owes much to aerodynamics. Yet the repeated compression of gaps can create a curious result: cars remain close, but closeness becomes ordinary rather than exciting.

Watching one driver recover a ten-second deficit through pace, tyre management or strategy creates an intelligible story. When a similar deficit disappears through a restart, the following contest may be spectacular, but the preceding achievement has been partly discounted. A spectator who expects the field to be regrouped may increasingly decide to watch only the final laps. NASCAR's decision to abandon the single-race, winner-takes-all championship finale for 2026, returning to a ten-race Chase, suggests some recognition that season-long achievement ought to carry greater weight.

The underlying question is not whether organisers should ever change the rules. All sports are constructed around rules, and some changes genuinely improve fairness, safety or accessibility. The issue is whether an intervention reveals more opportunities for meaningful competition or merely produces a greater frequency of apparent drama.

The need to endure a contest is itself part of what gives sporting outcomes their significance. In baseball, for example, a pitcher taking a no-hitter6 into the eighth inning generates extraordinary tension through the continued absence of a dramatic event. Each ordinary pitch becomes more consequential precisely because the achievement has not yet been completed. The pursuit of continuous excitement may therefore reach a point of diminishing returns: when every passage of play is expected to be dramatic, exceptional moments lose their relative meaning.

The Tour de France has developed a more constructive way to sustain interest over three weeks. Alongside the general classification7 are competitions for points, mountains and the best young rider, with intermediate sprints and climbs creating further objectives. These are inventions of organisers, so they cannot be described as purely organic. But they provide several forms of genuine achievement within the race rather than repeatedly erasing the progress of those competing for overall victory. A stage with little movement in the yellow-jersey contest may still contain an absorbing struggle elsewhere.

This brings me to a less intrusive way of increasing engagement: rather than continually modifying sport to generate excitement, improve the audience's understanding of the meaning already present.

A baseball broadcast might speak to a coach during an otherwise quiet inning. Football relies increasingly on tactical analysis, former players and statistical explanations. Done well, these reveal patterns that are not obvious to the casual spectator. Yet having played at the highest level does not necessarily equip someone to explain the game. Analysis requires an ability to translate experience into an intelligible account of decisions and consequences.

There is also a limit to what can reasonably be explained. Sometimes both football teams play badly, tactics are poorly conceived or instructions are badly executed. An analyst who insists on finding an intriguing tactical narrative may irritate viewers who can see the quality of the match for themselves. Roy Keane can be valuable precisely because he is prepared to say that a match is awful. From the broadcaster's perspective, he appears to be criticising the product. Yet candour may strengthen the audience's confidence in the broadcast rather than diminish it.

Data has a similar obligation. Statistics that illuminate pressing, positioning or the decisions facing a player can be valuable. Those introduced merely to create a talking point are another form of manufactured significance. Broadcasters have two related assets to protect: the entertainment value of the event and their own credibility as interpreters of it.

I would not romanticise every delay, traditional rule or inherited inconvenience. Nor is sporting uncertainty valuable merely because it is unpredictable. It becomes valuable when spectators can understand how an outcome arises from what competitors have done, and why the consequences matter.

Sport is unusual among entertainment products because its most memorable moments cannot reliably be scheduled. In a television drama suspense can be written into the script. Sport derives much of its suspense from consequences that nobody entirely controls. If organisers work too hard to guarantee excitement, they risk weakening the connection between effort, achievement and result that makes those moments worth following.

The more sustainable commercial opportunity may be to preserve that connection and become better at explaining it. The audience does not always need more excitement. Sometimes it needs a better understanding of why what is happening matters.

Explanatory notes

  1. Designated hitter (DH): A player who bats in place of the pitcher without taking the pitcher's defensive position. The National League adopted the rule permanently in 2022, after a temporary exception in 2020. MLB glossary. Back to text
  2. Virtual Safety Car: A conventional Safety Car physically leads the cars at reduced speed, typically bunching the field. Under the Virtual Safety Car, drivers slow to a prescribed pace without forming a queue, so more of their existing gaps are preserved. Back to text
  3. NASCAR: The National Association for Stock Car Auto Racing, the US organisation that sanctions stock-car racing series, including the Cup Series discussed here. NASCAR history. Back to text
  4. Next Gen car: The NASCAR Cup Series vehicle introduced in 2022, incorporating a standardised chassis and many common or approved-supplier components, while allowing manufacturer-specific engines and approved body shapes. Back to text
  5. Stage points: NASCAR divides races into stages and awards championship points to leading finishers at intermediate stage ends. A caution temporarily slows the race, with cars regrouping behind the pace car before a restart. Back to text
  6. No-hitter: A baseball game in which the opposing side records no hits. Reaching the eighth inning without conceding a hit means the pitcher is close to a rare achievement, but it is not yet complete. A game normally consists of nine innings. Back to text
  7. General classification: The Tour de France's overall ranking, determined primarily by each rider's accumulated time across the stages; its leader wears the yellow jersey. Other classifications reward different achievements. Back to text

All insights